INTRODUCTION
Drama-in-Education (D.I.E.) methodologies provide the teacher of C.S.P.E.
with techniques derived from drama which are used to invite stUdents
to explore a given issue, story , case- study and so on. In this article
I intend to focus on hot-seating.
Hot-Seating:
Description
This technique invites one or more pupils in the role of characters
associated with the given story/issue/case-study, to take the hot-seat
and answer questions put by the rest of the class.
I tend to use hot-seating as a follow-up technique to freeze-framing
and thought-tracking and I give it a class period of its own. In order
to encourage volunteers and to protect the individual student from feeling
targeted or from 'drying up' , I usually invite two pupils to represent
each character. Either character is, therefore, free to answer the questions.
the "shadow." character giving support and supplementing the response.
As pupils become more experienced in hot-seating, 'shadowing' can be
eliminated.
I find it best to hot-seac several characters at once. This approach
spreads the questioning and answering. giving it a broader and more
real context and encourages more insights and a more lively and enteraining
exchange.
Example: Hot-seating:
Going National (Exemplar Material for Unit 3 "The State - Ireland")
Section II: Redundancy: Clare's Story, P. 38-39.
How Would you
Feel?
During the first few minutes of class time I invite those who will be
identifying with the selected characters to sit together in pairs and
to re-create the character for themselves, encompassing as many details
from the story as possible and supporting them where necessary The selected
characters could include John, Clare, John's employer. Clare's mother
and other such characters emerging from the sub-text and the story .Each
pair continue to discuss and familiarise themselves with their characters,
thus four to six characters are emerging spontaneously and simultaneously
around the room.
Meanwhile, during the same few minutes, the rest of the class is divided
into groups of three or four, representing different lobbies and viewpoints
that emerge in the context of redundancy. Their task is to short list
the relevant and burning questions which should be asked of the panel
from their group's perspective. The teacher might select from the following
groups or better still the students themselves might suggest who they
are:
*Group I: A Trade
Union Group representing John's interests
* Group II: A team of social workers
* Group Ill: Members of the local Citizens' Action Group
* Group IV: Members of the local youth group
* Group V: A group of psychologists specialising in the study of employment
It is indeed possible
for the students to ask questions as themselves. but they tend to be
more self-conscious and less focused when themselves. The pupils-in-role
technique allows them the freedom to identify with other viewpoints
and hence to ask questions they would otherwise not consider .
The next twenty
to twenty-five minutes of class time is taken up with hot-seating the
various characters. In order to give the event a sense of occasion and
urgency, I tend to present the exercise as a live TV presentation, part
of a chat show or current affairs programme. This implies that from
time to time during the show, I side-step into a parallel role, that
of some well known presenter. The students know that when I take up
my microphone, for example, I am someone else (not necessarily in voice
or looks!). They are quite prepared to suspend disbelief in the interest
of getting on with the hot-Seating and I am comfortable in a role which
is akin to my teaching one, allowing me to field questions and to ensure
that all get a fair chance to question and answer. It is possible to
hot-Seat the characters without the teacher-in-role framework and without
the 'studio' setting, but invariably, I find the more dramatic context
more productive and more enjoyable for students and teacher .
Loosening
up the 'square' classroom structure is also important and invites more
pupil questioning and involvement. I tend to sit my 'audience' in a
semi-circle, putting the desks aside and adapting the classroom space
to resemble that of a 'studio audience' .Those in the hot-seat face
the class/cameras from their 'comfortable studio chairs' (minus the
desks!); the 'shadow' characters sitting beside or standing/sitting
behind them. During the final five or ten minutes of class, I invite
the students to reflect on the hot-seating exercise and to acknowledge
that the redundancy problem must be examined from various perspectives.
For homework, I invite those who were representing vested interest groups
to write one to two paragraphs highlighting their perspective and to
make a list of the questions they asked of the panel. I also invite
them to say whether or not they were satisfied with the answers. The
homework exercise for those in the hot-seat invites students to tell
their story in the first person from the perspective of the character
involved. I also encourage them to recall the more 'thorny' questions
and to record their responses.
Hot-Seating:
Observations
Hot-seating
is a useful technique for eliciting precise information regarding the
topic being explored and the people who are affected by it. It invites
the class to gain perspective on the issue by identifying with the attitUdes
and conflicting views of various interested and affected parties. It
also deepens the pupils' understanding of the key characters involved
in the story and adds complexity and motivation to their thoughts and
actions. It can be used with any class and most subjects in junior or
senior cycle, since the questions and answers of students define their
understanding of the issue being explored at their level and on their
terms.
|